Unofficial Partner

Share this post

2022 in 13 opinions; The way we thought; AI v McKinsey; Enabling dictators and other hot sports biz trends; Why RICHWHITEMEN love LIV; ChatGPT and the journey to irrelevance; Grant Wahl RIP

unofficialpartner.substack.com

Discover more from Unofficial Partner

Overthinking the sports business, for money
Over 3,000 subscribers
Continue reading
Sign in

2022 in 13 opinions; The way we thought; AI v McKinsey; Enabling dictators and other hot sports biz trends; Why RICHWHITEMEN love LIV; ChatGPT and the journey to irrelevance; Grant Wahl RIP

Opinions are cheap, but then again so are we

Dec 15, 2022
33
Share this post

2022 in 13 opinions; The way we thought; AI v McKinsey; Enabling dictators and other hot sports biz trends; Why RICHWHITEMEN love LIV; ChatGPT and the journey to irrelevance; Grant Wahl RIP

unofficialpartner.substack.com
Share

Apple Podcast Review of 2022


The Unofficial Partner 2022 Opinion Generator

Our 13 most clicked on stories of the year.

  1. Value Creeps - Infantino Explained

  2. 17 things to think about when preparing to attend a web3 brainstorm with people who actually know what they’re talking about

  3. What was the point of London 2012?

  4. Six mistakes that lie ahead of women's football

  5. That Girl Didn’t: What would a British Title IX look like?

  6. 16 ways in to the Spotify Barcelona story

  7. What Man Utd’s sale price says about us

  8. The Graeme Souness Guide to Culture War

  9. What’s the point of British Cycling?

  10. The Unofficial Partner Web3 Brainstorm Live at Emirates Stadium

  11. Beware the siren call of cricket in the US

  12. Ooh, sports biz friends! 15 questions when attempting to build an industry network

  13. IMG’s all-you-can-eat future


Theme 1 of 2022: The answer’s Drive To Survive, what was the question again?

This week’s addition to the pile of BTS sports docs.


Theme 2 of 2022: The business media’s unwavering faith in RICHWHITEMEN

Four RICHWHITEMEN were asked if they’d invest in LIV Golf, the Saudi sportswashing meets Greg Norman breakaway league.

(Thanks to Dan Haddad of Octagon for linking me in to this on Twitter)

Twitter avatar for @flushingitgolf
Flushing It @flushingitgolf
Business leaders talking about the business plan of LIV is an interesting listen. I guess guys like Mark Cuban have no idea what they’re talking about? Professional golf has done the same thing for decades and is ripe for disruption! Via @LIVGolfUpdates
7:02 PM ∙ Dec 13, 2022
47Likes6Retweets

First, a word on the format, which is very on trend for sports biz 2022.

By gamifying the investment decision, the slow plod of business reporting can be rendered sexy. (An approach that led to the 2008 financial crisis, btw)

So, it’s LIV Golf as culture war. Padel as an existential battle between them and us. Etc.

The clip contains 4 features of Journalism as Entertainment:

  1. The media’s absolute faith in RICHWHITEMEN as the source of truth.

  2. The way in which the finance bros present general cliches and abstractions with bullet proof certainty.

  3. The bias toward the new and untried over iterating an imperfect status quo.

  4. The thrill of catastrophising, and the media’s role in maintaining an atmosphere of continuous pessimistic uncertainty.

Cuban, Leonsis etc are bullish on LIV in principle, but that doesn’t tell us anything we don’t already know.

The problem with LIV, previously noted, is not the idea, which has many interesting themes - global, teams, antidote to a complacent PGA Tour etc.

But the breakaway is incomplete. Stuck. (McKinsey has put numbers to this scenario, see below).

And worse than that. It’s really, really boring.

Compare the views of the RICHWHITEMEN with ChatGPT, the AI tool that’s currently writing your kid’s Sociology A Level essay.

ChatGPT can’t answer specific LIV questions because it’s data scraping isn’t up to date.

But it can match Mark Cuban, generic sports biz cliche for generic sports biz cliche.

This week, New York Times broke a story that takes us inside that McKinsey’s original LIV Golf deck. There’s some revealing details.

In its analysis, McKinsey called the golf league “a high-risk high-reward endeavor.”

They ain’t kidding.

The consultants detailed three possible outcomes for a franchise-driven league: languishing as a start-up; realizing a “coexistence” with the PGA Tour; or, most ambitiously, seizing the mantle of dominance.

In the most successful scenario, McKinsey predicted revenues of at least $1.4 billion a year in 2028, with earnings before interest and taxes of $320 million or more. (Federal records show that the PGA Tour, a tax-exempt nonprofit, logged about $1.5 billion in revenue and posted a net income of almost $73 million for 2019.)

By contrast, a league mired in start-up status — defined as attracting less than half of the world’s top 12 players, navigating a “lack of excitement from fans,” reeling from limited sponsorships and confronting “severe response from golf society” — stood to lose $355 million, before interest and taxes, in 2028.

So, + $320m to - $355m.

Given LIV currently feels like a ‘languishing startup’, I wonder if Mark Cuban’s still interested?


Theme 3 of 2022: Enabling the worst people in the world

It’s worth pausing on McKinsey for a moment.

Because the famous consultancy is emblematic of something broader: Sport’s enablement supply chain.

Major events are held in places you wouldn’t choose to live and controlled by people you’d cross the street to avoid, but from whom you are happy to take money.

It’s a pact that’d make Faust blush.

This amorality runs alongside the corresponding rise in brand and purpose, which makes us all feel better about ourselves.

Psychiatrist have a name for this trick, it’s called compartmentalising.

Compartmentalization is a form of psychological defense mechanism in which thoughts and feelings that seem to conflict are kept separated or isolated from each other in the mind.[1] It may be a form of mild dissociation; example scenarios that suggest compartmentalization include acting in an isolated moment in a way that logically defies one's own moral code, or dividing one's unpleasant work duties from one's desires to relax.[2] Its purpose is to avoid cognitive dissonance, or the mental discomfort and anxiety caused by a person having conflicting values, cognitions, emotions, beliefs, etc. within themselves.

See: How McKinsey Has Helped The Stature of Authoritarian Governments

“Like many other major corporations including our competitors, we seek to navigate a changing geopolitical environment,” the company said, “but we do not support or engage in political activities.”

Still, some analysts, veteran diplomats and experts on global governance see McKinsey’s role in a different light.

While the United States pulls back from international cooperation and adopts a more nationalist stance, major companies like McKinsey are pursuing business in countries with little regard for human rights — sometimes advancing, rather than curbing, the contentious tactics of America’s biggest rivals.

“It is more likely they enable these regimes and likely become complicit,” said David J. Kramer, a former assistant secretary of state. “They don’t want to alienate regimes, or they would lose business.”


The Long View

Pickleball got hot in ‘22.

But, have a look at how tastes change over time.

@malidesidero26 @malidesidero26 ♬ orijinal ses - Malibu
Tiktok failed to load.

Enable 3rd party cookies or use another browser

Nice Threads

Twitter avatar for @sillytuna
Sillytuna x Soulcast @sillytuna
2023 will be a difficult year for crypto Here’s why:
4:05 PM ∙ Dec 12, 2022
7Likes2Retweets
Twitter avatar for @fmccrindle
Fi McCrindle @fmccrindle
🧵 A look at every Premier League club's most liked tweet of the year (so far) and what we can learn from them... #digisport | #smsports
1:13 PM ∙ Dec 12, 2022
2,951Likes294Retweets

Grant Wahl

I first heard Grant’s name when he stood against Sepp Blatter for FIFA President.

Then I read his excellent book, The Beckham Experiment.

I’m sad I only got to know Grant via remote podcasts, email exchanges and shared stories.

As has been noted many times elsewhere, he was a very generous man, who went out of his way to help others.

This is a lovely piece, by his wife, Céline Gounder.

Grant appeared on UP twice. Here and Here.


Click the like button to help us game the Substack algorithm.

It helps.

Happy Christmas.

33
Share this post

2022 in 13 opinions; The way we thought; AI v McKinsey; Enabling dictators and other hot sports biz trends; Why RICHWHITEMEN love LIV; ChatGPT and the journey to irrelevance; Grant Wahl RIP

unofficialpartner.substack.com
Share
Comments
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Unofficial Partner
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing